Tuesday, 17 November 2026

A Review of Mistress of Mistresses by E.R. Eddison






This might rank amongst the strangest books I have ever read, much stranger than 'The Worm Ouroboros' which I reviewed here: 

 https://falsemachine.blogspot.com/2019/03/a-review-of-worm-ouroboros-by-er-eddison.html

 And you can hear me talk about it with Tom Fitzgerald here: 

https://archive.org/details/TheWormOuroborosWithTomFitzgerald 

Most of the very broad strokes about how society in these stories works, about the fashions, the nature-poetry, the masculine adventure, all hold broadly true, in 'Mistress', but more has been added.

 

 

Pagan Portal 

This is a Pagan text, literally a prayer, an act of worship. It’s also a wargame, a Jacobean play, a written catalogue of high 19thC academic art paintings, a wardrobe of incredible costumes and a dynastic drama. Tolkien did not like the 'Worm' because he thought Eddison was “corrupted by an evil and indeed silly ‘philosophy’, he was coming to admire, more and more, arrogance and cruelty”. Perhaps. I read this as a conflict between Eddisons essential paganism and Tolkiens Christianity. Send a Saint to burn down his Tree. This light world of Zimiamvia is dark in subtle ways. It is an adventure after the adventure, and no-one in it seems to change, and simply dies again. Is that a happy place? 

Like 'Worm Ouroboros', this is a portal fantasy, the opening section is a strange short story, thick with themes and symbols. We begin in, (or in a version of,) the 'real world', with the death of a Hero and the grieving of his extremely homosocially-connected Best Friend. 

Vast swathes of 'Mistress of Mistresses' are built around love relationships between men and women, but especially between men. I have no idea if they are banging. It’s a judgement call, dealing with men of Eddison’s culture and generation, whether or how much his magnificent men and their intense relationships involve them doing stuff behind the bike sheds. It is entirely possible that Eddison was very gay, or a bit gay and displaced all those very intense feelings into hero worship and glorying admiration, or that the structure of society and the people in it at that time, allows for, and provokes, complex and sometimes intense waves and storms of homosociality that are unfamiliar to the modern west. It’s time to gaze intently into each other’s eyes, grasp each other, and perhaps duel. 

We begin in a castle on a Scandinavian island 'ruled' by the lover, noble, artist and adventurer; LESSINGHAM, who now lies dead! Our narrator is Lessingham’s younger and slightly less-cool best friend who is grieving him, and present also is 'the Senorita', Lessingham’s most recent lover. 

In the world of E.R. Eddison, Lessingham does not pump and dump, but adores, seduces, paints, ennobles, worships and Sadly Parts with various beautiful women, a mutually-enlivening and pain-free exchange. We could carp, but this is a story of ideals, if we will not take it as it is, we may as well not read. It is flawed, it is sincere. Lessingham was a True Lover. Knightlike. No skeletons in the closet. 

The Narrator recalls his earliest meeting with Lessingham in an amazingly well-described English Country Church, and, prompted by the Senorita, their subsequent adventures, exploring, mountain climbing, somehow ending up in charge of this island, being mysteriously rich, considering rebelling against the Norwegian government etc. He lived like a hero till the end. 

And there is a secret, the secret of the missing woman; for Lessingham, very young, had a wife, who he never mentioned, and who died within a year or so of their marriage. Lessingham  burnt down their house in response, then hunted down every painting, mention or description of her and destroyed those too. Our narrator (young) thinks at first that this is because Lessingham hated his wife, but eventually realises, and we learn too, the opposite is true. Prompted and provoked all the while by the mysteriously beautiful 'Senorita', the narrator fulfils the last parts of his friend’s Will and Testament, (after which he is meant to burn the castle down, with Lessingham’s corpse inside it) he takes the MYSTERIOUS KEY gifted to him in the will and opens the MYSTERIOUS CABINET in Lessingham’s private room, directly above the bed on which he now lies. 

 

"The cabinet doors were of black lacquer and gold, flush with the wall. I turned the golden key, and opened them left and right. My eyes swam as I looked upon that loveliness that showed doubtfully in the flittering candlelight and the diffused rosy dusk from without. I saw well now that this great picture has been painted for himself alone."

 

Of course she was there all this time. And more, there is a poem about the mystery of ZIMIAMVIA;

 

"I heard her say, faint as the breath of night-flowers under the stars: 'The fabled land of ZIMIAMVIA. Is it true, will you think, which poets tell us of that fortunate land: that no mortal foot may tread it, but the blessed souls do inhabit it of the dead that be departed: of them that were great upon the earth and did great deeds when they were living, that scorned not earth and the delights and the glories of earth, and yet did justly and were not dastards nor yet oppressors?' 

'Who knows?' I said. 'Who dares say he knows?' 

Then I heard her say, in her voice that was gentler than the glow-worm's light among rose-trees in a forgotten garden between dewfall and moonrise: 'Be content. I have promised and I will perform.'"

 

Because it turns out that the Senorita, as well as being the Senorita, and probably a real, actual woman, is also Aphrodite. And Zimiamvia is real. Whether it is heaven, or something stranger, and what it means to have a second life beyond the first, we shall see. 

 

Fashion, Paintings, Prose 

Another luxurious book, another hymn to nature and light and more exquisitely fashionable dudes. Everyone is magnificently dressed at all times. You could probably do a whole picture book just on the fashions in the works of E.R. Eddison. 

“.. and now the trumpets, after a long baying blast that seemed to shake the gossamer tracery of the roof, suddenly fell silent as Barganax appeared. 

His kirtle was of corded silk, rose-coloured, slashed with velvet of a darker hue, and gathered about the waist with a belt of sea-horse hide lapped at the edge with thread of gold and bossed with balas rubies and cat’s-eye chrysoberyls; he had thick-woven silken hose of the like rose-colour, and a long cloak of dark grey brocaded silk lined with cloth of silver; the collar of the cloak was of black cormorants feathers cunningly sewn and fitted to make an even smoothness, cross-striped at every span with lines of rubies and fastened with golden clasps.”

 

Portrait of Sir Walter Raleigh (1588, National Portrait Gallery)

Not everyone gets a glorious fashion-parade every time, but everyone who matters does. Eddison thought a lot about how people were dressed and their dress has no real direct comparison for me; maybe 1950s technicolour movies about Ruritanian duchies, maybe theatre, but the fashions of theatre are too shallow. In Cinema, perhaps Coppola’s Bram Stoker’s Dracula, or ‘The Cell’. 

If the scenes of ‘Worm’ were a little like theatre, especially the paper-figure theatre, then ‘Mistress’ is a lot like very fancy and somewhat horny 19thC academic painting; 

“In Acrozayana, in a jewelled shade of strawberry-trees, where the sun speckled the gravel path with moidores strewn upon a carpet of cool purple, the Lady Fiorinda rested as music rests when the lute is laid by. Her couch was cushions of wine-dark satin on a bench of porphyry. Her gown, very soft and fine, long-sleeved, close fitting, yellow of the pale cowslip petal and with narrow ruffs at throat and wrist, settled at every gently taken breath to some fresh perfection of her as she rested there, sweetly gathered up, upon her right side, her feet along the bench. A hood of black netted silk, rebated at the border with chrysoprases sewn upon cloth of gold, framed her face as with an aureole within which, betwixt white brow and jewelled tissue, her hair was like the mystery of night set betwixt bright sun and moon. 

Below her to the left, on the step of the carved porphyry seat, sat Rosalura, her needlework fallen on the ground at her side, her hands clasped in her lap. Anthea, clothed in white, stood on the confines of the shade and the sunlight of the lawn without: the pupils of her eyes were slits against that brightness: there was in her bearing, an alertness of expectancy: her hair, loosely gathered and knotted up in a disordered grace, was as fire burning. Bellafront, at the outer end of a low bench on the left, close to Anthea, caught the rays too on her coiled plaits of chestnut red. Pantasilea and Myrrha, Campaspe and Violante, reclined these upon this bench those upon that, of the two low benches to Fiorinda’s left and right. All were as if listening to something afar off, or, may be, to the humming of the bees only that droned on the summer air, now louder, now more dim, but never silent; listening not as hearing but rather hoping to hear some expected thing. 

Doctor Vandermast, in russet-coloured gaberdine, walked in his meditation. The little arrows of sunlight piercing the leaves, rained upon him ceaselessly in his measured walking.”

 

Frederic Leighton - The Garden of the Hesperides

 

This is a painting (Duke Barganax himself is a painter in the story and ‘real-world’ Lessingham was too), Suggestions are: Frederic, Lord Leighton, Albert Moore, William Etty, John William Waterhouse and Lawrence Alma-Tadema. 

‘Mistress’ moves through paintings. It is a story of beauty, of immensely beautiful people wearing beautiful fashions moving through beautiful paintings, doing beautiful things and having beautiful emotions. 

Lastly, the prose. Anything I said in my review of ‘Worm’ still seems true. The diction, rhythm and address feel as if ripped from an imagined Jacobean play, with a lot of additions, enhancements, playful archaisms, (scattered over every page), invented poetry, transcribed poetry, poetry in French and Greek, with Greek text woven in. Everyone is a Trinity College Oxford graduate (maybe the only similarity with Sally Rooney and her Trinity College Graduate paracosm), and this was written for an audience of about 500 guys who all read English, French and Greek equally well. When your audience is under 1k 130 IQ Anglos, who all went to Oxford and maybe Cambridge you don’t need hypertext, notes or explanations to make text multifaceted, just drop some Sappho in the original, the boys will get it. 

When characters open and read Letters, which they do oft-magnificently, or fearfully, for these usually contain dread or wondrous tidings, these are given in X-tra-Jacobean prose; 

“As touching my sayde kyngdam of Mezria, save and exept the sayde apponage of Zayjana as herein before prouided, I doo point my wel beloud faythfull sarvante the Lorde Hy Amerall IERONIMY….”

 

In description, and this is largely a story of description, Eddison marinates himself in a rich Miltonic stew of simile and metaphor. Nothing is ever as it is, or only what it is, but carries with it a bright shadow; 

“fleet as a viper’s his eyebeam flashed upon Lessingham’s face” 

“But the rumour, once sown, ran like quitch-grass in a garden, much underground, yet to no bad effect.” 

“in a sleek-petalled wan paleness as of old ivory, from the dark calyx of her skirt of black silk spangled lace”

 

The tongue of ripe comparison interpenetrates through the high poetic mould, when heroes and ladies are introduced; (men are like stars, lions, or winds or suns), to scenery, to lesser moments, and into the language of the characters themselves, who likewise live in a capacious world of bright, vivid, sensuous and poetic comparisons. These people, condensed of sensation, are themselves libraries of subtle sensation. 

 

The Lovers of Zimiamvia 

We fade into existence, in medias res. Lessingham blinks as if he is remembering something, then listens to his friend Amaury discussing the extremely important dynastic drama they are currently engaged in; the Great King Mezentius, tyrant of Fingiswold, Meszria and Rerek, is dead, his young son, the new King, is also dead (mysteriously), his daughter, now Queen, is a teenage girl. In the south Duke Barganax, the courtly, capable and honourable bastard of the late King, seems like a decent option. Assigned as the Queen’s protector in the young King’s will is Horius Parry; The Vicar, cousin of Lessingham. To the north the Kingdom of Akkama looks with covetous eyes. The Queen is young, the next best choice looks good, and her ‘protector’ is a very bad man, whom Lessingham loves. Which way will Lessingham jump and what will become of Meszria, there’s your drama. 

Lessingham, Barganax, and many of the main cast, are alternates, or shadows, or mirrors, yet they take, at strange times, a little part of each other. They transform into one another. They see each other in the other’s eyes. And some of them are Aphrodite. 

A host of characters occur but these are the main groupings, with one or two of those I found more interesting; 

 

The Parrys 

Horius Parry -  Lord of Laimak and 'Vicar' to the king. Referred to by everyone as 'The Vicar'. A thug. Most captivating character in the book. A villain and perhaps *the* villain of this story. He loves NO ONE, is an enemy to all the world, except perhaps his cousin LESSINGHAM. Likes his dogs, who he fights on the regular. 

Gabriel Flores - a slimy little dude, conspirator, secretary, coward and master of assassins. Fears and adores The Vicar and is one of few men even slightly trusted by him. Hates LESSINGHAM for being the best. 

LESSINGHAM - the nominal protagonist, all around amazing dude. Errol Flynn crossed with a young Richard Burton. Fighter, lover, soldier of fortune, swordsman, courtier, just the best guy ever. His only real weakness is his quite genuine, and quite strange, love for his brutal cousin The Vicar. Is mirrored in BARGANAX and becomes the (psychic) lover of Queen Antiope. 

Amaury - LESSINGHAM's secretary. Hangs around serving him nobly and occasionally saying things like "Don't trust the Vicar" or "maybe be less impetuous". Is the narrator from the opening story. Has his own loves and relationships in the background. 

 





The Children Of King Mezentius 

Duke BARGANAX - the semi-legitimate son of King Mezentius and Duke in his own right of Zayana. Is Zimiamvia-Lessingham if he kept the practice of painting. Enemy of The Vicar, lover of Lady Fiorinda, is mirrored by Lessingham, who he occasionally becomes. 

Queen Antiope - a teenager. Thrust into being Queen rapidly after the quick successive deaths of her father and her brother. Is threatened on all sides in a courtly, and then military, manner. Gets some of the rare non-divine female character development and moments of women just being women and not moons, the night or divine Lovers. (Though still not enough screen time). Loves (via psychic mind palace) LESSINGHAM. Sometimes becomes Aphrodite. Is mirrored by Lady Fiorinda. It could be said she fails to 'lock in', but she's a teen (Elizabeth I would have locked in).

 Lady Fiorinda – the extremely edgy and 19thC goth lover of Barganax and also Aphrodite more often even than any other woman.

  

Some Other, Less Cool People 

A whole host of Lords, Ladies, Knights, Courtiers; they are cut from the same cloth; swords, horses, a castle somewhere, occasionally noble, somewhat treacherous. One or two have individuality; 

High Admiral Jeronimy - a competent, non-glorious man in middle age, with notably sad eyes. “the whole aspect of the man melancholy, and as if strained with half-framed resolutions and wishes that give the wall to fears.” Relatively sane, broadly on the side of Barganax. A good advisor and more solid and competent field commander than average, but usually loses to the main cast. He was fighting on land! It's not his element! 

Doctor Vandermast - a mysterious bearded scholar who hangs around with Barganax. Continually quoting Latin and Sappho. A straight-up wizard, he has magic leaves that open locks, can turn animals into sexy girls and has access to a psychic fairy mind cottage where couples go to hang out, become each other and have mind-sex off screen. A fervent devotee and servant of Aphrodite from whom he gets much of his power and insight. Also produces much of the Pagan Theology of the book, which makes up its most boring chapters. 

Derxis - king of nearby Akkama. A chud who cannot hang and who no-one likes. Exists to be a villain but honestly not even interesting. Does his job (of being a jealous villain) and gets out. The story seems overwhelmingly uninterested in him and so am I. 

Anthea - one of Vandermast’s several sexy animal-women who he hangs out with. She is slightly darker and more memorable than the others, based on a Lynx. 

None of these guys get mirrored or reflected in each other’s eyes (that I noticed).

 

 

Everyone is Everyone Else 

Under the influence of Aphrodite, who passes through the women in the story like the flu, men become each other, see their lovers in each other’s eyes, have intense sword fights, look this is all sounding much more explicitly gay than it comes across in the books but a core concept of 'Mistress of Mistresses' is of these souls mirrored, divided, across realities and across persons within realities, people see themselves in other people and all of these pairs are in love, or see each other through some kind of love. 

I don't think we ever see Lessingham’s first meeting with Barganax but here is a notable one; 

"There was in his voice as he spoke a lazy bantering music, full of charm, redolent too of sleeping dangers. Amaury, that had been bred up with him to manhood, knew it like his native air. Vandermast knew it too, but not till now in a man's voice. For it bore, even as the troubled image in a lake at midnight to the star it mirrors, some kinship to that languorous mocking lazy music that awoke so often in the Lady Fiorinda's voice; and Vandermast thought he knew, looking at the Duke, that the Duke too felt the spell of it, albeit without recognition, as a man listening to an air which he knows yet cannot place."

 

Later, after an extremely mysterious courtly hangout involving river boats and a singing faun, Lessingham is guided, or influenced, to walk the Duke’s palace at night and comes upon Barganax and Fiorinda being painterly in the throne room, but Fiorinda is not Fiorinda;  

"For now in her, so facing him from beside the dream-stone, he beheld no longer that lady, but another. In her hair, too pale for gold, too golden for silver, braided with strings of pearls, light itself seemed fallen a-dreaming, caught and stung asleep by the thousand little twisting tendrils that floated, hovered, vanished, and glinted again, with every stir of the quiet air. Feature by feature so might have been Barganax had he been born woman: a golden girl, in the sweet holiday spring-time of her awakening beauty. Her grey eyes drew to far spaces, like the sea. On her cool lips, full, clean cut, pure of curve, every thing desirable on earth or heaven seemed delicately to slumber."

This is the face of Queen Antiope, the half-sister of Barganax, who she resembles and who Lessingham has not yet met, but when he does, they will fall in love.


Sandro Botticelli - Idealized Portrait of a Lady

At this moment Fiorinda is possessed by, filled with, Aphrodite. They are all taken by the goddess now and then, in a dream-like state, and there is no line between their mortality and divine spirit, no notch in the text or the world. She glimmers under them and at times grows brighter. 

About this time Lessingham and Barganax nearly kill each other, but decide not to, which is something else that happens a lot. Later, they swap souls in the mind-house of Vandermast. 

 

The House of Heart’s Desire 

A kind of Fairy Cottage which, in the moments between breaths, summons Lessingham and Antiope into it; 

“She dropped reins: pulled off her gloves: began gathering with her fingers the coil of hair which, heavy, pythonlike, of the sheen of palest mountain gold, was fallen at her neck. Lessingham made no answer, neither moved. This that she looked on was become suddenly a thing to darken sight and shake the stability of nature. The wind was on that sudden fallen, and no breath stirred. On the stillness came a flutter of wings, of a wood-pigeon flapping down unseen among tree-tops. The Queen looked round into Lessingham’s face. The stillness laid its finger upon her too, even to the holding in of breath. Like a lute-string strained in an air too thin  to carry sound, the silence trembled. The Queen parted her lips, but no voice came. 

At a grating of hinges upon the left, Lessingham swung round in his saddle to behold, with eyes startled as out of sleep and dreams, a wicket gate that opened in a low red brick wall smothered all over with dark red climbing roses.”

 

Here in a House of Heart’s Desire, Lessingham and the Queen love as if in a dream or stupor, drifting, served by fairy spirits; 

“Lessingham felt himself sink into a great peace and rest. Strange and monstrous shapes, beginning now to throng that room, astonished no more his mind. Hedgehogs in little coats he beheld as household servants, busy to bear the dishes; leopards, foxes, lynxes, spider-monkeys, badgers, water-mice, walked or conversed or served the guests that sat at supper; seals, mild-eyed, moustachioed, erect on their hind flippers and robed in silken gowns, brought upon silver chargers all kind of candies, conserves, macaroons, fig-dates, sweet condiment and delicate confections of spiceries; and here were butterfly ladies seen, stag-headed men, winged lions of Sumer, hamadryads and all the nymphish kindred of beck and marsh and woodland and frosty mountain solitude and the blue caves of ocean: naiad and dryad and oread, and Amphitrite’s brood with green hair sea-garlanded and combs in their hands fashioned from drowned treasures of gold.”

 

Sir Joseph Noel Paton - The Quarrel of Oberon and Titania

Here is where, in a strange lucent modernist way, the identities cross over and blur. Rarely in ‘Mistress’ is anyone seen casting a spell, instead meanings shift in the middle of sentences and paragraphs beginning from one point of view end from another with no direct statement or indication. One thing passes into another. Identity is not fixed. This seems strangely modern in a very creaky, gleefully pseudo-archaic book. 

Antiope and Lessingham, after who knows how long, leave via the magic of a shifting paragraph; 

“Through the wide-flung casements of Antiope’s bed-chamber in that wayside house came the golden-sandalled dawn: the sky in gold and without cloud, and the sun more golden than gold in the midst of it. The Queen said, at Lessingham’s side, ‘Thanks my lord, I’ll take my reins again.’” 

And back we are, exactly at the moment that we left with not a second passed, and everything a dream, but a shared dream. And Lessingham and Antiope can continue to share this dream, whenever they wish, disappearing within their own minds, even in the midst of great events, to a place no-one else can see, where they can spend however much time together they wish, and come back to reality, together, with no time having passed at all. This is also where Barganax and Lessingham cross over into each other, as they later discuss; 

"He met Lessingham's eyes through the dark. Inch for inch he and Lessingham stood of a height. It was as if he could not easily resolve to let loose that which was upon his tongue. At last he spoke: 'Lessingham, I can, as I said, answer none of your riddles. But I will tell you this: upon Michaelmas night, taking my ease in a certain house of Vandermast's, I looked in a mirror and I beheld there not my own face, but yours.' 

Lessingham neither spoke nor moved. 

'Well,' Barganax said. 'What was it? Know you such a house?' 

'And I beheld', said Lessingham, stare for stare, 'your face, not mine. In that house. Upon Michaelmas night." 

This is a great contest of crossing-loves, but one love is strange and out of place, and is also the only element making this story an actual drama; Lessingham loves his cousin, The Vicar, and the villain; 

[The Vicar] "'And, cousin, this is the maggot in the oak-apple: you are clean fallen in love with yonder little wagtail at mere hearsay.' 

Lessingham answered and said, 'With you, cousin, I have long fallen in love.'"

 

 

The Vicar 

In 'Worm' a world of Glorious gilded heroes and iron-dark villains carried in its teeth the pearl of 'Gro', the most flawed, most human Goblin of the cast. Though 'Mistress' is a book of gilded lovers, it has some loveless figures; Vandermast, the Admiral, and king Derxis, but if there is a 'most-human' figure in the book, it is one of the worst people in it; 

"..he stood, all in dirt, stripped to the waist, aproned like a smith, with a long wooden vat or tub before him full of steaming soapy water, taking his pleasure with washing of his cursed dogs. 

... 

He was a huge, heavy, ugly man, nigh about fifty years of age, not as tall as beside tall men, but great-thewed and broad of chest and shoulder, his neck as thick as a common man's thigh, his skin fair and full of freckons, his hair fiery red, stuff like wires and growing far down on his neck behind; he wore it trimmed short, and it had this quality that it stood upright on his head like a savage dog's if he was angry. His ears were strangely small and fine shaped, but set low; his jaw great and wide; his mouth wide with pale thin lips; his nose jutting forth with mighty side-pitched nostrils, and high and spreading in the wings; his forehead high-domed, smooth and broad, and with a kind of noble serenity that sorted oddly with the ruffianly lines of his nose and jaw; his beard and mustachios close-trimmed and bristly; his eyebrows sparse; his eyelids heavy, not deep set. He had delicate lively hazel eyes, like the eyes of an adder."

 

Jean des Bandes Noires Offices Florence


We find him fighting dogs, biting dogs, wrestling dogs and washing dogs; 

"..she laid back her ears, snarled, and snapped at his leg; he caught her by the neck and beat her with his fist about the ribs and buttocks till she yelped for pain; when he had done she growled and bared her teeth; he beat her once more, harder, then waited to see what she would do."


 Then, bathes her, kindly. Then, frustrated and enraged by Lessingham being late (he was playing tennis), and poisoned against him by Gabriel Flores, he throws a dog at him; 

"She, with the gadflies of pain and outraged dignity behind her and a strange man before, sprang at his throat."


 Lessingham smacks her with the racket. 

"'God's death!' said the Vicar, 'will you kill my brach?' and threw a long-bladed dagger at him."


 They wrestle, nearly kill each other, both go into the dog-tub and before more people come in; 

"The Vicar barked out a great laugh, and held out his hand to Lessingham, who took it straight. There was in Lessingham's eye as it rested upon his cousin a singular look, as if he fingered in him a joy too fine for common capacities: such a look as a man might cast unknowingly and because he could not help it, on his dear mistress. And indeed it was strange to consider how the Vicar, standing thus in nasty clothes, but even risen from a rude tussling bout and a shameful fall, stood yet as clothed upon with greatness like a mantle, sunning in his majesty like adders in warm beams."

 



Every scene he has is like this; dogs, violence, nearly killing each other, playing it off. At one point they draw swords on each other, another dog dies, and as the Vicar’s men are beating down the door, Lessingham throws a bag of gold coins on the table and laughs it off; 'You have won the bet my cousin!'. Another time, after Lessingham wins a battle for him, but makes too kind and politic a peace, the Vicar captures him, ties him up in a dungeon and leaves him there with a hungry dog;

"'It was prettily done to leave me your bitch for company.' 

'What's this?' said the Vicar. 'The Devil damn me! I had clean forgot her.' 

'I had thought,' said Lessingham, 'you were hard put to it to make up your mind, and conceited you might cast her for the part of Fate. A chained man: 'twas a nice poising of the chances. I admired it. And you feed 'em on men's flesh now and then I think? of ill-doers and such like.' 

'I swear to you cousin, you do me wrong. By all the eternal Gods in heaven, I swear I had forgot her. But let's not talk on this-' 

'Waste not a thought upon't. I ne'er slept better. Being of that sort, may be 'twas that made her take to me.'"

 

I can kind of see why Lessingham loves this guy. He captures something that his world does not have, in a reality of harmonised, verbose, fashionable and courtly masculinity, the Vicar is the only masculine outsider. Gabriel Flores and King Derxis are both losers, Vandermast and the Admiral are old, they all have places in this world, but Horius Parry is the only man without a place, he is a vision of manhood neither weak, cowardly nor old, but horribly un-cultured, and not 'good', he is 'Virtu', raw, the base engine of a man’s heart, with nothing meaningful for it to do. But strong and unafraid. And though awful, he has these tenuous glimmers of humanity. Perhaps Lessingham loves him because Eddison loves him and Eddison loves him because he is a creature from Norse, rather than Greek, myth, and because he is strong and vital and Eddison worships those things. I like him, though I know I shouldn't, (he would set his dogs on me while laughing), maybe because of this utter outsider status. In a world defined by grace, beauty, luxury, rhetoric and love, he has only strength and love alone. A love that even he doesn't really understand. The Vicar Horius Parry, who loves no man but only beasts, and that slightly, also loves Lessingham, as he describes to his personal Wormtongue, Gabriel Flores; 

"'But truth is, you were right in reason, my pug. And truth is, I cannot well digest reason in this particular, for truly I cannot root out of me the liking I have for the man; having both already made my profit by him and wishing still to do so; and yet, little commodity I see in't, as things sort. And yet,' he said, 'I have a kind of love for the man,'"

 

Then, after their last and final argument, brought about by Lessingham trying once again to save The Vicar from his own grim schemes, and to persuade him to more sane and pro-social behaviour, again to Flores; 

"'Go, I'll tell you,' said the Vicar. 'There is i' the camp here, and walked from this chamber not ten minutes since, one that hath to-day with so many and vile injuries abused me and borne me such derision as, not were he set upon the inflexible purpose to destroy himself might he a done more. I will use him no longer. Choose your instrument: let him think this is done i' the Duke's service"

 

But! Even after arranging the treacherous assassination of the one person in the whole world that he loves, in the very moments before Lessingham’s (3rd hand) murder; 

"'You look merry, cousin,' said the Vicar as they walked. 

'Not merry,' Lessingham answered: 'contented.' 

'With that you have? or with that you look to?' 

'Contented,' answered Lessingham, 'that all sorteth now to wished effect: power where, were it mine to give, I would give it; and our sword, not now to be escaped neither eluded, lifted up against our enemy.' Upon that word, there seemed a triumph to clothe him, such as stars wear rising between clouds in a gale at sea, when all perils of night and shipwreck are become but a carpet unrolled for those flaming feet to walk on. His eye, as from that pinnacled certitude, met the Vicar's, that till now had avoided the encounter. 

They halted. The Duke on his white pawing stallion, with the Chancellor upon his right and the Meszrian lords in great splendour about him, was approached now within twenty paces and still came on. Trumpeters sounded the royal salute. In Gabriel's secret ear the Vicar flung a sudden word: 

'I have changed my mind. Prevent it.'"

 

One look is all it takes! Lessingham, drawn by something, some respect or desire or recognition of mad unreconstructed masculinity, and the Vicar likewise drawn to the only man alive who doesn’t fear or hate him, who can fight him to a standstill but never seems to resent him, his only friend in all the alien world. 

It is too late.

 

 

Deciding for Each Other 

With the Vicar causing chaos in the south and a freshly enraged Derxis to the North, Antiope and Lessingham must decide what to do; 

“Lessingham took a great breath. He turned to Aphrodite’s statua in its cold high beauty, netted and held in the loneliness of starlight. ‘Let Her’, he said, ‘choose for us.’ 

‘Be it so,’ said Antiope. ‘There is no other way of wise choosing.’ 

‘Let me look at your face,’ he said. She raised it to his under the stars. 

After a while, he spoke in a whisper. ‘What mystery was this? Looking but now in your face, I have been my own love: seen myself: loved myself, being myself you for that instant, Madonna: chosen for you, and for me, with your love as from withinwards.’”

 

This is the last choice they get to make together and is probably the wrong one. Lessingham goes south and defeats everyone but hears news that in his absence, the Queen is Dead, at the hands of the vile King Derxis. After having a total breakdown, he brilliantly gathers all the former enemies for a war of vengeance against Akkama, but is Foully Betrayed by Horius Parry and assassinated. 

I found ‘Mistress’ less directly-pleasurable than ‘Worm’, and a lot stranger. This book has many more odd wonders and strange effects, it’s dark and luxurious and has a vivid, deep philosophy which I disrust. It also has a lot of Doctor Vandermast doing Theology, which I found a bit tiresome.

 

 

A Dark Prayer for Aphrodite 

Everybody dies at the end. I like this not. Fine if you are Aphrodite though. As if any of that mattered. It was all provoked, planned and arranged by her or by her intermediary Doctor Vandermast. The goddess is somewhat monstrous in this, though I think the book does not believe it.  

“’Your ladyship doth play with me,’ said Vandermast. 

‘I play with all things,’ she said. It was as if that which dwelt in the corner of her mouth shot its arrow and then buried its face again for very sweetness of the place it dwelt in. Her right hand made a rest of her cheek; her left arm was thrown back and fallen behind her, behind the proud arch of her hip, as in a carelessness and divine largesse of the treasure of her body, ethereal as the scented thought of a white rose, beautiful as golden flowers, the fairness of it and the Grecian pride. ‘With all things,’ she said. 

‘And rightly so,…’”

 

Love, and doomed love, justify themselves under Aphrodite’s rule, but any single human principle, even the most noble, can become horrific if given sole, absolute command of entire lives, and though Ares (the wargame aspect is strong), also has a presence here, this book in all its aspects is a real and genuine hymn to The Goddess. Tolkien was right to be suspicious. When there is no God, and no good, no principle but love, even in a painted world made for just such a story, it seems to me that things run darkly. Lessingham doomed in reality and doomed in fantasy. For Aphrodite, this is fine, the temporal and vulnerable nature of the love between Lessingham and Antiope makes it better, finer almost, because it is brief, intense, devouring, doomed, a perfect sacrifice. But generally we do not want our lives to be a perfect sacrifice to a Goddess who, in this book, is merciful, sometimes, but more often playfully cruel, indifferent, like a cat with a toy, she is not a human being and her interest in us is as vectors for desire, which she loops and plays with. 

Well, all Gods have their darkness.

 

Agnes Miller Parker - Mvtability

 

Monday, 27 July 2026

The Common Store of Monsters

 I am slowly grinding my way through the re-writes for Veins of the Earth. As part of the re-write I have re-organised the ‘Pariahs of the Earth’ monsters section into a list of sixty creatures, expanding some concepts and re-doing others. Some of these are ‘Re-Skins’ or re-conceptions of common D&D monsters, some are descriptions of whole cultures.


The current list;

  • AntiPhoenix
  • Arachnopolis Rex
  • Archeans
  • Atomic Bees
  • Blackfoot Tapper
  • Calcinated Cancer Bear
  • Cambrimen
  • Castilian Caddis Larvae
  • Chaos Goblins
  • Cholerids
  • Civilopede
  • Cromagnogolem
  • Dead-Eyed Dwarves
  • Deep Janeen
  • dErO
  • Egg Dead (PseudoOolites)
  • Eigengrau
  • Fossil Vampire
  • Fungal Ambassodile
  • Funginid Slaves
  • Gegenschein
  • Gilgamash
  • Igneous Wrath
  • Ignimbrite Mite
  • Knotsmen
  • Lamenters
  • Mantis Shrimp
  • Meanderthals
  • Mondmilch
  • Olm
  • Once-Men
  • Oneirocetacean
  • Opal-Winged Chiropterae
  • Panic Attack Jack
  • Phantom Hand of Gargas
  • Psychomycosis Megaspores
  • Pyroclastic Ghouls
  • Radiolarian
  • RayMen
  • The Rapture
  • ScissoFish
  • Silichominids
  • Exploration
  • Substratals
  • Soft-Heads
  • Sonic Pigs
  • Spectre of the Brocken
  • Splinterlads
  • Spotlight Dogs
  • Still-Tor-Men
  • Stormsheep
  • Tachyon Troll
  • Tetracharcarodron
  • TitanSkull Hermit Crab
  • ToRaptoise
  • Trilobite-Knight
  • Trogloraptor
  • Ultraviolet Butterfly
  • Zombie Coral


Encounters

A major part of the re-write is a focus on usability and part of that will include encounter tables. And part of that will be a discussion and instruction on just how encounter tables can work, with a very basic workshop for anyone who doesn’t already know about them describing, for instance;

  • The way combined-dice rolls can produce probability curves and how you can use those to produce pseudo-natural encounter tables that might simulate the more interesting elements of an imagined environment - something that is carrying on without the PCs and which they happen to be going through.
  • How you can make very ‘big’ tables of this kind for large volumes to give them a kind of identity, but also smaller ones for different more local environments
  • Straight-roll single-die graphs of various sizes and how those produce a generally different tone of reality, something a little more ‘event focused’, and how and where in the game you can use those, and how often and where you can re-use them, based on what they are doing.

The aim here is to give people the tools to create their own ‘family’ or ‘toolbox’ of tables, ones they make themselves to suit their own style of game and a simple ‘starter list’ of encounter tables and similar, to go with the map-making and world-populating sections. I imagine the reader building and populating their map, making notes on it on another piece of paper, and creating a small, efficient, handful of tables to go with them.


COMMON MONSTERS

The question then becomes; is it reasonable for me to tell the reader about other common D&D monsters? And if so, how much of a description should I give?

I have taken out any creatures where I have basically done my own version and only included ones in the SRD

NOT IN THE SRD, DO NOT USE

Beholder - a big loss, can I steal ‘Eye Tyrant’ from someone?

  • Mind Flayer - Have ‘Soft Heads’ so fine.
  • Umber Hulk - I will learn to live without you.
  • Kuo-toa - I am sorry guys you are dull plus I have Olm.
  • Githyanki - Too Planescape
  • Githzerai - Too Planescape
  • Slaad - Very cool but can live without them, also not very ‘Underworld-specific’
  • Displacer Beast - as above
  • Yuan-Ti - guys you are less interesting than you sound
  • Carrion Crawler - Carrion Crawler I will miss you bro but must build a life without you

Is there an own-brand numbers-filed Eye Stalk Bite Globe guy I can use?


General Humanoids

We need these guys! They are the meat and potatoes of encounters! (Though I still took out ‘Orcs’ and their general family as I felt in an environment with big dangerous intelligent humanoids they don’t really have a strong identity in the underworld.)

  • Grimlock - Blind humanoids. ‘Savage’. Have a really good illustration in the 3.5 Underdark book. Feel like these guys are a winner.
  • Kobold - Petty lizard-dog things. Kind of boring and I’m not sure there’s any reason they should exist but they do. Famous trap-users allegedly. I suppose they can go in? Every paracosm needs something specifically lame as fuck I guess.
  • Troglodyte - Colour changing, dumb as bricks super-stinky Lizard-people? I have never seen these in a game. At least slightly more interesting than normal Lizard people. Alive or dead they smell REALLY BAD. Very dumb. I think I like these guys?


Boring Fauna

Fire Beetle, Giant Centipede, Giant Bat - I mean fine.


Ambush Monsters

  • Ettercap - dull, hangs out with Spiders
  • Giant Spider & Giant Wolf Spider - The Wolf Spider will get off the web at least so there is that.
  • Gibbering Mouther - honestly pretty cool, I may have mis-categorised this one but no-idea where else to put them except in ‘Weird Guys’.
  • Otyugh - vital recycling, probably someone will complain if you kill this. Static I guess. More of a location.
  • Phase Spider - annoying but interesting to fight.


Burrowers

Literally built for it.

  • Ankheg - meant to burrow through soil so not fully appropriate but good to keep around for old times sake maybe? Will he be lonely without the Umber Hulk?
  • Bulette - presumably having a great time underground.
  • Purple Worm - technically a burrower but honestly deserves its own thing. A good Big Dangerous Monster.
  • Xorn - kind of basically like meeting a guy really? Just a guy who eats gems.


Dead and Dry

There are too many of these and many are dungeon-specific. I did imagine a lot of undead underground but also imagined them semi-civilised, part of society and subject to law in a way they are not usually and able to converse.

  • Bodak - deadly gaze, ok?
  • Crypt Thing - the ‘teleports everyone’ guy, but basically a skeleton, very Gygaxian, surely this guy would have an actual job in the Veins?
  • Demilich - jewelled skull, no worse than meeting a millionaire underground.
  • Huecuva — ‘The undead remains of a faithless priest, cloaked by illusion to appear a living, robed cleric’ I guess we can have this guy. Is he still doing the predatory false priest thing down here?
  • Lich - Classic. Again, just like meeting a Mayor or something.
  • Mummy - classic, more like meeting a person than a monster.
  • Revenant - Revenge-based murdered corpse, possibly wet, but if in the Veins, maybe in some kind of existential mission, maybe more like meeting a weird guy.
  • Skeleton - classic, in the Veins, should be like meeting a guy.
  • Winterwight - what even is this? Is this new? A cold Skeleton I guess.


Dead and Wet

Feel like there would be proportionately less of these underground as they are made of valuable meat.

  • Coffer Corpse — “A drowned or grave-cheated corpse that strangles the living; it collapses as if destroyed, then rises moments later to renew the attack.” Surely too annoying to have in the Veins. Feels wrong.
  • Ghoul - I kind of have Pyroclastic Ghouls already, also, in the Veins, probably more like meeting a guy, if they are smart enough to last this long.
  • Mohrg — “The animated corpse of a mass murderer, its exposed organs bound in rotted sinew; a lashing tongue paralyses prey for its raking claws.” Very cool and weird but probably no, not unless in special environments or circumstances.
  • Penanggalan - As above, cool but probably no.
  • Wight — Cool enough to probably go in the ‘dry’ list. Also like meeting a guy.
  • Zombie - a poor fit this deep down, also I have ‘Cholerids’ already.
  • Vampires! - Already have these. Definitely like meeting a guy.


Dead and Not There

  • Caller in Darkness — “A roiling mass of death-agony born where many people died together in terror; it assaults the mind directly, drowning victims in others’ final moments.” Honestly very cool but I already have the Panic Attack Jack which is essentially this but the caving version plus corpses. So, maybe?
  • Ghost - Classic. With living and dead communities being more integrated this will be just a dude who isn’t there.
  • Mohrg — “The animated corpse of a mass murderer, its exposed organs bound in rotted sinew; a lashing tongue paralyses prey for its raking claws.” Knarly. Nearly wet. Probably a ‘No’ or ‘Nearly never’.
  • Poltergeist — Not as bad as the Mohrg but limited use for you, sorry.
  • Shadow - Honestly fine if they have some personality and reason for being there.
  • Spectre - freezy touch, generic, absorb into ‘Ghost’, along with Poltergeist.
  • Will-o’-Wisp - A classic but probably semi-tamed or at least negotiated with underground.
  • Wraith - A super-ghost? Ghost boss? Lets just say this guy is the other Ghosts boss.


Dead and What the Fuck

  • Atropal — “A stillborn godling risen as undead — a bloated, cosmic-scale horror whose touch withers and whose gaze slays.” What the actual shit I have never even heard of this. Keep I guess? Sounds fun.
  • Devourer - “A gaunt, towering undead with a smaller trapped soul writhing in its ribcage; it consumes the spirits of the slain to fuel dark spells.” Never heard of them. Too wet and specific for General but might be fun to keep around.
  • Nightshades (Nightcrawler, Nightwalker, Nightwing) - I don’t know anything about these guys! I guess they can stay? I am too scared to throw them out.


Fucking Annoying Lurking Trap Things

Cave Fisher, Cloaker, Darkmantle, Grick, Mimic, Piercer, Roper - fine fine fine. I think I kind of hate these things. They are traps not encounters really for me, but some are classics and they have A place, even if I don’t like them. I don’t think most should be on an encounter table but putting them in a place in a dungeon-equivalent map or something is fine. Can anyone explain how the fuck the Cloaker and Darkmantle both exist and are they materially different in any meaningful way?


Slime and Oozes

I kind of slightly hate these guys too but less than the weird trap things. They have their place.

  • Black Pudding - corrodes metal, splits, fine.
  • Gelatinous Cube - Classic. Keep. The best of the slimes.
  • Gray Ooze - hidden, acidic, eats metal, sounds shit. Ok, keep.
  • Ochre Jelly - bright yellow, acidic, divides, flows, ok?
  • Shrieker - not a classic but a familiar type. Static, put with weird trap things.
  • Violet Fungus - the shrieker but worse. Static, put with weird trap things.


Big Cool Main Monsters

  • Aboleth - I can’t believe this guy is in the SRD! Thank you Wizards of the Coast!
  • Basilisk - not very underground-coded but sure I can find a use for you.
  • Behir - I have to confess, I do not find you very interesting but I am reluctant to throw you out.
  • Chuul - Chuul you have no real identity for me but I will give you a chance.
  • Drider - I reskinned Drow but I WotC is willing to hand you out, you are too cool to let go.


So!

What do you think of my scheme here? Is it reasonable?

Did I miss any actually-good and Veins-appropriate monsters (that are in the SRD)?

Should I go back through all my own books and make another list of my (and Scraps) own monsters? Or is that cringe?

Should I put in monsters from other independent creators books? (single-line descriptions with references to the books); probably still no, sounds shady & cringe. But if someone has done a really good one is it bad for me to say ‘check out the so-and-so from such and such a book?’ (Still probably a bad idea))

Did I miss any publicly available and good, Underdark monsters?

Thursday, 16 July 2026

A Review of 4th Edition Underdark



I was broadly demoralised by this damnn book, but to make it bearable to get through, I will make a list, from back to front, of everything I actually liked.


TOROG - The King Who Crawls



The Level 34 Solo Lurker Himself! (“Huge Immortal Humanoid, XP 195,000")

God of Torture, Imprisonment and the Underdark. A few concepts in here govery hard indeed and Torog is the best. Entered the Underdark to fight some primordial horror in the Dawntimes and was cursed even as he killed it. He cannot heal, cannot leave, and as a God, cannot die.

Trying to escape the Underdark, Torog crazily crawled his way through the whole of the planet. He was cursed to never reach the surface, but he could madly smash his way into other planes, so long as it was into the Underdark of those planes. His crazed crawl created a permanently bloodstained Godroad which curls and spirals madly through the Underdark, and even breaches the walls between realities.

Now his palace is the hewn corpse of the Titan he killed to get here and Torogs servants have to constantly chew and cut away at it to stop it re-growing. Bitter, wrathful and in constant pain, Torog tortures and imprisons people, turning them into wracks. Unlike other Gods, he does not share his power or trust his angels. If he wants to communicate he will either send some horrid low level servant with his words sliced into its back, or the big guy is coming himself, in person. He likes to take cities of people who piss him off, and pull them down into the Underdark. I imagine this happening like two mountain-sized hands rumble up from the earth on each side of the city, fingers like arcologies, curling over, then down, down down.

Torog is so depressed he may actually want to die, which would form a neat apex to a long campaign. The guy was just messing with you because he wants to commit suicide-by-adventurer.

If he does die, he horrible presence is the only thing keeping the Abberant Outer Realms from infiltrating and merging with the Underdark, which will end up with Mind Flayers, Beholders and Grell turning everyone into pâté, which is a neat piece of setting-sustaining divine engineering.

Torog is novel, functional, has a cool picture and really holds the book together. Its not surprising they made the whole thing about him.


The Incunabulum




Vecna-Worshipping sort-of humans defined by Mum-Ra Drip. Obsessed with discovering and recording secret knowledge of all kinds, they have “the grisly ritual of the Unveiling” which strips every piece of memory from a (dead?) subject. This involves the questioner eating the subjects brain, which gives them access to their entire experience. BUT, the interrogator has only 12 hours to write down parts before the memories fade. They keep these secrets on parchment, (which is probably made from the victims).

The Incunabulum are culturally defined by their wrappings. When they come of age they are given a set of wrappings derived from dead Incunabulum. These contain knowledge and memories, and once they go on, they don’t come off till death.

The lore says elements of these memories date back to the first Incunabulum. The nature of replication and dispersal means that, while there must be continuity, I’m sure there will be a lot of alteration, adaptation, splitting and drift in what feels like a ‘written genetic signature’, each Incunabulum having access to a kind of edited, pathed together palimpsest of memories, dating first to one or two predecessors, and from them, back and back and back, all the way to the first. The patterns created by the memories no doubt being stronger than the details of the memories themselves, each Incunabulum being a kind of evolved book of memories, as well as a person.

I’m already interpolating too much into a very sparse 4e text. These guys look largely human, they hang out in a Cavern-Venice City called Glimmer in the Shadowdark, worship Vecna exclusively, make a lot of use of (dry, never wet) Undead, and generally love secrets and being evil. Good villains with some unexplored Borgesian depths.


Blood Ooze

A bad Ooze monster with fragments of interesting elements. One - its made from Torogs blood. Two - if it manages to Ooze you it gets inside you and puppets you. Three - “A blood ooze has no allies.” A koan to place alongside “Giant Oysters are never surprised.”


Lathan, River of Souls




“The lathan forms where streams of souls join together in a crevasse known as the Vale of Sighs. Here the moaning torrent becomes a true flow as spirits funnel through the narrowest part of the canyon ... its surface and depths are made of a rushing press of intertwined and glowing spirits.”

“Devils frequently sail the Lathan to the Soul Slough to find souls that had been promised to them. They float atop the spirits in iron-keeled boats and fish spirits out with ghost catching nets.”

“Only at one place along the Latham does a permanent crossing exist: the Worm Bridge. .. Its master, Bragarra the Bridge Witch, controls it constantly to keep it from being dashed to pieces by the tormoil of the Lathan.

The bridge is crafted from the corpse of a purple worm whose long body forms a tunnel through the water to reach the other side. On either end stand a pair of nightmares chained to the dead beast, and dark stalkers lurk nearby, ready to obey their masters commands. Nearly frozen and unable to move more than its head, the purple worm must be pulled up and down the river to compensate for the water’s movement. The dark stalkers drive the nightmares to draw the worm taught for crossing, and sin its coils deep to avoid floating dangers.”

Bragarra the Bridge Witch is very Chris Avellone-coded.


Esaham, Graveyard of Demons

This is actually a pretty bad section, but the very idea of a graveyard for Demons, a place of binding and repose for what are meant to be sempiternal, extra-causal entities, is provocative.


Icegloom Chart





Bad name, good concept. A fat shard of ice. “Barely visible channels and bubbles in the ice constantly reshape themselves to resemble a map,”


Fire Pit

One very good fragment from an overall tiring 4e ‘Encounter’.

“This magic fire pit burns only meat and leaves wood untouched.” From an encounter in the Feydark. Excellent Druidic/Ent horror concept.


Deadtrees

“These four titans shed dappled shadows over thier realm while gods and primordials still warred.”

Four primeval and long-fallen Tolkienesque super-trees. Their roots though, still exist, and now form tunnel systems. Very fey concept for the Feywild, but interesting.


Sick Gnomes


The GNOMES are wilding the fuck out.

“King Finutar’s court magicians assure the people of Drochdan that the haze is a hostile sending from a rival kingdom - perhaps the formorians. In private,some gnomes whisper that it is a curse ...”

“In reality, this magical ailment is spread by contamination of the Drochdan’s food supply by fungal spores. This fact explains why entire gnome hunting bands are stricken by it at the same time - they’ve all eaten the same rations.”

Look, even mildly interesting GNOME CONTENT is rare.


Inbharann


A Formorian Kingdom that has learned how to mass-produce Sauron-Eyes and uses them as searchlights.

They also have a neat succession system; anyone can be adopted into the Royal Family based on competence. When the Monarch dies they all have to fight it out. The war is over when one is left standing, however, if everyone dies, a tribunal decides which one fought with the “greatest cleverness”, and orders his or her resurrection.

Resurrecting the leader from a dynastic bloodbath is fun, and having a commission to decide which was ‘cleverest’ feels very loony-tune-talmudic.


Primal Mud

4e combat chess idea with mud which you can use to heal yourself. Stated in the text, this dries out when you call on its power. Unstated is that, if this is a pool of mud, you just healed yourself and then likely trapped yourself by drying the it out, which makes for a nice combat decision. Even better, in a combat situation with multiple liquid pools, drying them out here or there could make the place more or less navigable for allies or enemies depending on circumstance.


Mherkrull

“Just as Asmodeus rebelled against the god that commanded him to relinquish his power, so too do devils and angels alike occasionally challenge their lords. Those wise enough to recognise their error before being destroyed have no hope of mercy. Their only succour is to escape divine notice for a time, and those who succeed most often do so by coming to the cavernous godless realm known as Mherkrul.”

That’s nearly all we get.


Xarcorr - Realm of the Aboleths

Some reasonably funky environments are sketched out;

“The area around Xarcorr tumbles and twits as if in pain ... stone shifts and mutates without warning ... Thoughts drift through the passages like smoke, choking the minds of the unwary with the nightmare imaginings of abhorrent creatures..”

These roiling rocks have islands of relative stability.

The Dripping Jungle; ”abuzz with glimmering creatures that make their own light. Ghostly insects glow in gemstone colours through transparent shells. leechlike rodents leave luminous slime trails behind their slithering bodies. Great behemoths stand on legs as tall as ship masts that shine with radiant blood, stretching their ruddy necks to reach ceiling vegetation”

The Stone Gyre; “the rock becomes fluid - the stone of the caverns ripples and moves while remaining in a cave shape ... Up is whatever direction air can be found.”

The Toothy Plains; “vast, flat expanses of ceiling and floor roughly 200 feet apart. .... massive crystal monoliths that resemble jagged fangs jutting from the ceiling and floor ... “glide along the surface from which they project..”

Then, once you enter Xarcorr itself; “a strange, still point, disorientating both in its contrast to the surrounding chaos and in the alien nature of the realm. ... Xarcorr overlays the place in the world that its area covers. it is both in the world and not, and what was in the world before its coming remains behind the unreachable barrier of Xarcorr’s existence. No mortal knows what lies in the world beneath where Xarcorr now rests.”

Within; Dreaming Vaults “in these long chambers the aboleths keep captives of many races alive in a shared dream state. ... Their captors observe the effects aboleth plans might have on the real world by looking at the reactions the captives have and how the sleepers imagine others would behave.”

The Warp Web; “rivers of slimy water from all over Xarcorr ... float out into the open air and split into a latticework of waterways that dangle down into the canyon.”

The Preserve, where the aboleths “modify the environment in extreme ways, hoping to scrape open a hole in the weave of existance and find a conduit to the Far Realm behind the flow”



Grell Colony Politics

We have a nice page here digging into the varying philosophies amongst a colony of Grells. I feel like these my have been written by a very angry, very cynical vegitarian;

The Byoll (”Opportunity for Use”) “Their philosophy permits captured prey to avoid being eaten by performing a dangerous mission of the grells devising.”

The Glatt “Equanimity of Harm”) “The Grell philosophy Glatt holds that harm to prey animals is a necessary part of life, but that the moral grell parcels out this unavoidable hurt so that no piece of potential food suffers more than other members of its litter, tribe or group.”

The Jrall (”Feasting in Knowledge”) “Jrall philosophy argues that it is acceptable to torment and kill sentient beings as long as they are ennobled by knowledge first. Thralls are kept in clean pens and taught the simplest rudiments of Jrall belief in anticipation of the day when they will be slowly devoured alive.”

The Kragg (”Consume the Willing”). “Like the Byoll - from whom they broke in a murderous conflict years ago - the Kragg send captured prey to perform hunting missions or other quests for them. The Kragg do this as part of a braoder exercise in bending future prey to their will. They use their psychic powers to make their victims want to be eaten. Philosopher Kragg asserts that this is the only ethical way to devour sentient species.”



Hraak Azul



A massive living multiple-fungus fortress/environment colony, slowly moving through the Underdark, going who knows where. Pretty similar to the Fungal Environment in ‘Forgotten Realms: Underdark’, but now mobile and with a nice image and some extra details.


Dark Lake Ziggurat

Its a big black Ziggurat on a dark lake. Neat element is that it is multi-planar, and perhaps multi-causal. The same ziggurat, built by different races and cultures, in different planes, in exactly the same place, and perhaps with multiple histories even within one plane.

Kind of basic Lovecraft tbh but a big black ziggurat standing alone above a dark lake, miles beneath the earth, is still a banger image. Its also mildly funny/das that the Lovecraft inspired Kua Toa have a colony nearby and keep sending Fishmen into the Ziggurat to perform what they think is ‘sacred work’ (they are being randomly hurled through other dimensions and driven totally mad.).


Maelbrathyr

Maybe the only part of 4e Underdark that keeps some of the old ‘Infinity Engine Location’ energy from Forbidden Realms: Underdark. Maelbrathyr feels very much like a city laid out in isometric graphics, with a dark and edgy backstory and a series of personally dramatic bossfights with Chris Avellone-style tormented bad-guys.

Story is that an Underdark City put together a team of heroes to rescue someone from Torogs Torture clutches. This they did, but the King Who Crawls was annoyed enough by this that he reached up and dragged the entire city down into the earth, leaving it a tiered collapsed city of ruins and levels.

He also cursed the heroes who ‘stole’ his prisoner, even the ones who didn’t survive. Now they are immortal horrors, mad and evil. One a half fire half ice slug centaur in undying agony, one given mega-schizophrenias by being inhabited by the souls of the comrades he let down, who don’t like each other or him, and who change his body when they take over, and one guy trapped in an eternal hamster-wheel/orrery torture device who can only roll around forever. Hilarious. Good one Torog.


This Image




Is this “4th Edition” in the room with you now?



Reading this was like suffering a flashback to an old, dull, war. 4e truly is a depressing system, with a kind of brutal, nasty, cognitive weight. Going thorough the text I kept wanting to argue with someone who wasn’t there, and who hasn’t been there for fifteen years.

Building your entire reality around a series of boutique grid-pattern ‘balanced’ combat encounters (which the PCs can’t actually lose without fucking things up), drags the imaginative potential of the human soul into a pit of mediocrity and tortures it - glistering pools of blood torn from a god who can never heal and never die and which still stain the passage of the King Who Crawls, give a +5 to fucking a fucking evoking surge but disadvantage on heals or some shit, its just the most depressing stuff. Torog would approve.

Even the really good ideas, like the Incunabulum, which have potentially fascinating concepts behind them, are all designed to be communicated via big dumb stat blocks, which are all built around combat-as-sport grid combat, its like watching fine French cheese be squeezed through a sieve onto the dirtiest burger.

Foaree Underdark also provides splatters of gaming advice, not so much wrong within itself, as the horrid product of post-apocalyptic mutational pressures producing something that approximates a previously health organism, but only through limb-splintering mutilations of an already horribly warped concept;

“One way to impress upon the players the dangers of the Underdark is tot talk about the deadly monsters that live there. But talk is cheap. I find that most players assume the DM will pit them only against foes they can defeat. They imagine difficult fights, but they also imagine winning all of them.

That’s great. D&D is at its best when its collaborative and everyone at the table has fun. Still, I like to put fear in the players and let them know that their decisions have real meaning in the game. If every choice has the same victorious result, the game gets dull.

I find the best way to do this is to call the players’ bluff. I’ll talk about some dangerous foe in a particular location, and if the players go there, they meet the danger. In effect, I put up a sign that says, “Here there be dragons!” If the players go past the sign, they meet a dragon - and not some wyrmling either.

The key to making this approach work is letting the characters get away. Some players might want their characters to run, but one or two often stick around to see if you mean it. (”Maybe that Mind Flayer is a doppelganger. He wouldn’t really have us face a Mind Flayer.”) This inevitably draws the others back to hep out, but after a few potent attacks from the monster, everyone should be looking for the exit. When they do, let them go. if you need a reason for the monster not to pursue, perhaps some other threat attacks it (the big fish being eaten by the bigger fish). If you do something like this in the Underdark, the players will give each other worried looks the next time they need to delve into the deep, dark caverns.

Using this technique has the additional benefit of teaching players that it’s ok to run from a fight. I’ve seen many campaigns come to an abrupt end or have to be saved by some deus ex machina because the players didn’t see a way out of a fight that went south. letting them run away shows them that their decisions have consequences, but that you’re still collaborating to make a fun game.”

Not a good book but there were at least some good things in it.