Saturday, 21 November 2026

What The Fuck Is Actually Hot in Indie RPG’s?

Amazingly and amusingly I have been invited to the ‘What’s Hot in Indie RPG’s’ panel at Dragonmeet this year. As part of this panel I need to actually pick something as ‘my pick’ for what is currently hot.

Having no actual idea what is hot or not, I started an intense and in-depth research program to work out what I should choose and here are the results, written as an exploration and adventure, if you will, as I go in search of the heat.

(I should state explicitly, if it wasn’t obvious before, all of these are my own dumb opinions and in no way reflect on Dragonmeet, the Panel or anyone else.)

Part One; BIG BEASTS - ALL PRAISE THE AMERICAN EMPIRE (which is not an Empire, and which will last forever)

The really massive ones come from a different world to whoever will be at this panel but they are worth considering because the similarities between them are illuminating and they at least give the British Small Press Audience context for the kaiju-reality we are all navigating.

Daggerheart

Storygame D&D and, judging by the reviews and awards, competently built. Lots of Ennies, looks like the design and product plan is pretty deep. Choobling son of Critical Role. Very Big Deal. Can you make adventures for this? If you can make adventures for it maybe that’s something we could do?

Dungeon Crawler Carl

Dungeon-Crawler Carl, despite being very deep into USA’n cringe, has strong anti-corporate themes, which is an odd parallel with other Indy stuff. RPG is from Renegade I think? $13 million crowdfund. TV Series is filming in 2027. Who the fuck designed this game? Are we ever allowed to know? Are gamers playing it? They will have a distributer at Dragonmeet so try to ask.

The fact this has a ‘game within a game’ aspect, with the A.I. as DM and an imagined ‘Audience’ in the game feels very ‘Paranoia’ and could actually be interesting, but this probably won’t be interesting and if I were taking bets I would bet it will be in the ‘Big Boxes Americans Buy to fill their Huge Homes’ and will be untouched and double-untouched in the U.K, but I could be wrong.

I feel in some strange way that there will be some kind of civil war or culture war between the ‘Carlists’ and everyone else at some point but I have no idea why I believe that. Possibly mental illness. I don’t sleep but I dream. Is cringe the true unanswerable frontier? I liked Hail Mary (the movie), please don’t put me in the literacy camps.

Crooked Moon

$4.2 million on Kickstarter in 2023. 5e World. ‘Folk Horror’.Choobling. They did a Sci-Fi Kickstarter in May for $15 million.

It’s 5e.

The Nature Of The Big Beasts

These the blossoms of old trees. The design concepts often 10 or more years old, 5e from around 2015 and a lot of *original* story game concepts date even back to The Forge. (Ron Edwards pauses in hoeing his pumpkin patch and glances mysteriously at the horizon while smiling in a knowing way).

All are linked to aural communities and two are Chooblings; Daggerheart is born of Critical Role, Dungeon Crawler Carl is a book series but is very well known for its Audiobook and fully voice-acted, maybe something more like a Radio play, performances, and Crooked Moon was a very long running streaming thing. Most of these are ‘Plaguetubers’ who got a big boost during Covid.

Many cross over with Short Form Video (Carl and I think Crooked Moon too.)

What strikes me about these is how deeply American they are. All group-play games are the Children of Loneliness, but these three seem to be the children of a specifically American loneliness; long car journeys, isolation, the desire to hear a voice or voices, the voices of friends.

Whatever is BIG in five years, will be just gestating now, and perhaps have its roots in concepts developed five years ago. Whatever is BIG in 2036, is likely just being developed now.

For an audience of British Small Press people; the enormous, totalising power of the U.S.A., a vast internal market with a single language and a very materially rich population, and enough cultural and economic dominance to assure that whatever it considers normal and desired is in fact normal and desired.

Like a lot of British businesses, we are in the position of selling something to the U.S. (the market for my books is two thirds USA) If it’s a physical something then the material stuff like Tariffs and various customs changes, becomes important, probably Robert Rees will be leading on that, I am eager to hear what he has to say!

- You can do adventures for Daggerheart, this might be a thing.

- If Dungeon Crawler Carl releases an SRD or something and next year everyone is making adventures and modules for Dungeon Crawler Carl (”we call ourselves ‘Crawlers’) I will literally shit myself laughing (then jump in front of the Jubilee Line)


SMALL BEASTS - THE WICKER MAN OF INDIE GAMES – pile in pile in

One step down from the Big Beasts, we get to people you might actually meet at a convention or hang out with. I hope you like Folk, Folk Horror, Storygame inspired rules and anti-corporatism. I feel like a metalhead who didn’t realise Disco existed stumbling into a Donna Summer concert.

Fatherfog

We got Crooked Moon, we got Dolmenwood, now we got Fatherfog? Which is... Mothership but Folk Horror? But it’s not Folk Horror its ‘Fairytale Horror’. Ok. What is it with dual-names and modern design? Games Workshop does this too.

Legends in the Mist

From Son of Oak game studio. Rustic fantasy. Low magic. Kind of a story game of sorts. Big on Kickstarter. Big at the Ennies. Made a ‘learn to play’ comic book adventure that is itself kind of a ludic object. Only one to do this? Try to get a copy of the comic book.

Triangle Agency

By Haunted Table but distributed through Modiphius. Did well on KS a while ago. Satirical anti-corporate. Book is a diegetic object; nice. Who is the audience for this? Anyone play it?

Draw Steel

Matt Colvilles creation. Choobling. Death is Not Dead Actually and you can still face potentially lethal challenges in this tactical 4e-ish move-em-around Combat As Sport game that people apparently like. SURGE. The Concept of a SURGE is still alive!



The Ruins of the OSR

It still kind of exists. Dolmenwood is doing ok! We don’t talk to each other any more. I should probably talk to all these people and try to find out what the fuck is going on with them. Remind me if you see me!

What Remains

Lamentations of the Flame Princess is still there. Lost Pages, Melesonian Arts Council (sort of), Soulmuppet (sort of).

Morklings

They won the Art War at least. Free League, Forbidden Psalm, Beyond Cataclysm.

People I Don’t Know at All (sell me on these guys)
Could they, in fact, be the ‘What’s Hot’ I am looking for?

· Squarehex

· Leyline Press

· Dice Average RPG

· By Odin’s Beard

I don’t know enough about what Rowan Rook and Decard are doing to have an opinion on them.

Blanchitsu and the 28 movement

This isn’t really ‘indie RPG’s’ but it is something I know at least a little about. For those who don’t know already, the art of the Late John Blanche spawned an entire art movement and this in turn spawned and synthesised with a parallel and branching indie wargames movement and all of this lead to the fact that in a modern wargames store before you are allowed in the bouncer will ask you for your ‘Grimdark’ World War One But Fantasy Inspired Wargame, and if you don’t have one, you are not coming in. (Chris McDowall did one, Mork Borg has one).

One of my not-actually-rpg’s picks for ‘What’s Hot’ is the Trench Crusade ruleset, because its one of the few game related modern texts I read this year and the art is very good. It also has a very good list of potentially asymmetric missions in the back.

If you are not into wargames, running an Indy skirmish game with sustained stats and resources etc across multiple sessions is actually way more like an RPG than you probably thought it would be. You also need to be physically present. They also combine zero-sum actual conflict (very non-modern RPG) with a surprisingly complex social contract under the hood, which feels very post-OSR.)

(I also suggested in a review or schitzo-post a while ago that once Blanche himself died his descendants would turn on each other for the crown in a Horus Heresy style and they did but only a little bit.)

Lots of Artpunk and old OSR energy in this scene. Could the RPGs ten years in our future be recombination’s or derived evolutions of the campaign aspects of skirmish wargame play? It makes slightly more sense than you are probably assuming; playing multiple characters or ‘support systems’ around the actual Player Character is already a thing I think.

CURRANTS!

The Death of Death

When I was a young-un there was something of a ‘culture war’ between the challenge-based ‘tactical infinity’ exploration, problem-solving, picaresque somewhat-lethal playstyle I associate with the OSR as I knew it, and whatever Storygames were because we didn’t know.

That argument is now decisively over and Storygames won, or at least birthed the Olympians who devoured them. People absolutely do not want what the OSR was offering. They want relatively soft, character based, low-actual-challenge play experiences that have their meaning as stories encoded into them and where you die, almost out of politeness, or as an act of grace. Death is dead, or not invited.

Folk Horror

There is apparently a semi-official definition of ‘Folk Horror’ so now we can argue about what is and what isn’t. There is also a weird confluence here between ‘Community’ (a massive ambient emotion in the meta), but in Folk Horror the ‘community’ is poisoned and bad-actually, so maybe this is all about nerds facing the irreconcilable nature of their own desires; to belong to a ‘community’, but unlike any actual village that has actually existed, a community of people that are already totally like queer-positive and not conservative or bad.

I guess in a nominally-horror game you can still allow death his dominion, so this is somewhere Death has gone to hide from Storygames, where he is only allowed by invitation.

Claude thinks there is a ‘Transatlantic Loop’ of British Folk horror being transmuted into ‘Over the Garden Wall’ and A24 films and then being sold back to us but is this really that interesting Claude?

Corporate Horror

Existing up and down the scale in surprising ways. Mothership, Triangle Agency and, most strangely, Dungeon Crawler Carl, are all about Corporations = Bad. Its not exactly a surprising take but it does tell you something about where the culture is at. The ambition of most of these people is probably to become one of the corporations they despise and Matt Dinneman is actually doing this but never mind. WHO ARE THE DESIGNERS OF YOUR GAME MATT?

Cosiness

Robert Rees wants to talk about this and knows a lot more about it than me. We got cosiness, we got community, we got the monster is racism and possibly grief, or a corporation feeding or racism and grief, we got Wanderhome, SoulMuppet, I don’t know, ask the other guy.

Actually, I do know; you collectively engineered worlds without unpredictable failure, wasted turns, boredom, of death, yet at the same time you all seem to sincerely believe you want to rebel against unjust systems of oppression. How exactly were you planning on doing that? Throwing your comfort pillow at them? No running your fantasy coffee shop is not Resisting Oppression, neither is journaling alone. Have you considered simply facing reality Head-On? Tooth-to-Tooth?

Solo Play

What the ACTUAL FUCK are you people doing? Did you find a new way to be lonely? There are over a thousand Journaling games on itch.io? I DON’T UNDERSTAND.

SPINE (Siderius Plug’s Immortality in Ninety-nine Endnotes) by Asa Donald - please someone tell me about this I know nothing about it. You read the book and deface, annotate and tear the pages and that’s the game? This feels like the kind of thing I should know about and I don’t. I am so fucking old.

The Bonsai Drawing ‘game’ - I want nothing to do with this. Do I? Is there an argument for this? What is the argument for this? I am more alienated from the Journaling players than the Carlists.

People who do this, how are you doing it? Are you journaling alone? Are you reading parallel in groups and then posting about it? Is there a ‘community’ at all or do you Enter Alone and Leave Alone? Is this even a game?

People who are making textual ‘GM Emulators’, or ‘Oracles’, who are you and what are you doing? Are you at Dragonmeet?

Tariffs

We are fucked more than you could possibly imagine. Probably not so much by the Tariffs themselves as books are technically exempt in the U.S. but by everything else, DPP, brokerage, clearance fees, RANDOM FUCKING BULLSHIT. Our job is literally sucking American dick from now until the end of time.

Even if the ‘Blue Wave’ takes the tariffs off, everything to do with sending small parcels around the world from the UK is shifting and changing all the time and this is my main source of business. I am going fucking mental trying to deal with new postage sheets from my fulfilment companies and re-calculating everything again and again, this is really bad for me personally.

(It costs me over a 1k I don’t actually have to shift a pallet of stuff to the US. I am trying to get stuff into the EU as well.)

I hope Richard Williams talks about this in the panel and/or that he knows what to do. If anyone else at Dragonmeet wants to talk about it feel free.

This is bad for UK small press especially. We are stuck selling PDFs and maybe cards. Or ideas.

Platforms

We got a battle on between Kickstarter and Backer kit, with Gamefound coming in with the steel chair. Despite running multiple Kickstarters I am bad at it and actually know nothing about it. Does anyone actually want to talk about this?

I guess the concept of ‘platforms’ overlays with the flight from corporations /resurgence of blogging with Bearblog, rootring and rpgtrader.com.

Also ‘Platforms’ being kind of their own culture and social media thing now - does everything just gradually turn into social media over time?

Very weird take from me but one of my potential choices for ‘What’s Hot’ is aYoutube Video from OSR manic James Raggi, from … 2025? Which is not a game but hear me out.



My Three ‘What’s Hot’ Choices

Please persuade me out of these and give me something better;

Wildlife on the Planet Furaha by Gert van Djik

NOT an RPG, yet,but definitely Indy and actually out this year.




Hear me out; there is a lot of energy in Speculative Evolution right now. ‘Furaha’ is not an RPG but it is a world and an entire reality, and is systematised, I called it’ “World creation as an act of pure joy. Crystalline, jewel-like. A planet *not* to have adventures on. (Unless they are careful, scientific adventures).”

But doesn’t that sound like a lot of current themes in game design? Furuha has jewel-like wonder, mild academic drama, exploration, can’t you imagine a journaling game on the Planet Furahra? I can.


Trench Crusade

Not an RPG but is Indie and is this year.

this is worth £150 on eBay! Should I sell mine?


Really good art. Careful worldbuilding. What looks like some excellent work in mission design. Morally complex and perhaps questionable. Do those who seek death inevitably seek war.


The James Raggie Spurn The World Video

Not an RPG and not this year and possibly the rant of a mentally ill man but also perhaps the wave of the future.



He is fucking loopy BUT, he has withdrawn almost totally from social media. Only the occasional YouTube and a static Substack page. The schizoid canary in the coalmine, my Prescient Patrick prediction is that he may be the first in a long line. In ten years, I am willing to bet, there may be a whole section of Dragonmeet made up only of Flesh-Pressers; fleshlings, simple solid three dimensional people with no social media, and maybe not even a webstore. If you want to see what they have you have to literally go there physically and physically buy it from them with your own flesh hands. This may be a real thing that could actually happen. FLESH. (Cronenberg speaks of this.)

1 comment:

  1. Fuck I forgot to mention the MASSIVE CHRISTMAS SALE I currently have on at https://falseparcels.bigcartel.com/

    ReplyDelete