Saturday, 11 April 2026

The Lost Great Crystal Debate

 
In a late and desperate attempt to shore up my ‘relevance’ I have been scouring the internet for evidence that I exist, and have stumbled into the tragic gap left by the lost ‘Great Crystal Debate’ DOES ANYONE EVEN HAVE A COPY? If you would like to find out more, scan down the following chronological list of text, video and audio discussions, down to 2018…
 

2015 – Podecast

 
Back in 2015 Scrap and I played around with a ‘Podecast’ (i.e. each was at the antipode to the other), and ended up recording a brief run of unedited ‘conversations’ about a rather wild range of subjects which ranged from 2015 into 2016
 
 

Podecast 1 - the Experiment




I honestly have no idea what is even  in this. Its eleven years old!
 

Podecast 2 - MONSTERS



https://archive.org/details/ScrapAndPatrick2a

Contents include; Rhiannas new video. Ghosts and why they hold candles. Skeletons and skeletor - egyptian theories of the dead. He-Man. Gas-Spores. Nazi Aurochs. “I’ve been around some pretty smelly subcultures.” Eating living things. Godzilla. Forbidden Planet. Imperialism and microbiology. Scrap fades in and out around this point for mysterious reasons. Possible collaborations. Natasha Allegri. Stephen Pyne. The state of modern poetry. The Art of Not Being Governed.(He wasn’t a poet.)
 

Podecast 3 - BEAUTY



Contents; http://www.stuff.co.nz/dominion-post/news/72404517/judges-take-a-shine-to-wow-winner. Zak hates nature. Snails. “The child of love and war is sex”. A thick silky coffee with cardamon. Crepuscular Rays. kelvin helmholtz. http://www.pncc.govt.nz/media/32138/citizensadvicebureaulogo.jpg http://www.firstlighttravel.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/Maori-Rock-Art.jpg

 

Podecast - 4 BEES 




Contents; 1.20 Scrap starts rambling about chromosomes. - (seriously, think about skipping this part). 4.26 Gives up on that and starts again. Begins a very dark story about Bees. 8.00 King Arthur and Bees. 9.55 The Demiplane of British History. 13.25 Brief ramble here. 13.40 Other Planes, verticality. 14.50 Hook Birds. 15.25 Dinosauroids - http://povorot.deviantart.com/gallery/9348116/The-Dinosauroids. 15.35 The first few issues of Prophet. (I think these are in fact the same guy.) 16.35 “Bees, have to get this back to bees..” 17.20 Evolution of pollen, and therefore bees. 17.45 Exploiting colony organisms. Pretending to be ants. 20.10 We are colony organisms. 21.20 The nihilism of not cleaning your room. 21.45 Emergency coping mechanisms. 23.09 Sudden change in conversation due to girlfriend interruption. The Death of Avril Lavigne. 24.24 Schizophrenia. The voices are probably real. Believing you are in the matrix. 26.13 “That’s kind-of like a hive..” 26.45 In stories no-one can ever be competent. 28.15 Destroying a city with super-speed. 30.15 The delay between conception and creation. 31.00 Cut-Up
 
 
 

2016 - Doom of the Podecast


Podecast 5 - relate-able content

-

https://archive.org/details/Podecast5
 
Contents; 1.30 - Dark gods. 5.00 - FotVH Images. 8.30 - Please buy my fucking books. 9.30 - Making relate-able and insightful points about a variety of role playing related conversation things. 10.30 - Alchemy. 15.15 - First impressions of the OSR. 19.30 - Motivations are monsters from inside you. 21.30 - Choices in char gen. 31.30 - Cognitive silence. 33.30 - Traditional originality, fire, hirelings and dogs. 37.30 - Ten minutes on dark AI’s & nightmare futurism. 46.45 - Language, objects & baby psychology. 51.30 - Lard, the currency of agency. 55.00 - Stories, memory and experience, the grand conflict. 58.30 - Fail states.
 
 
 

Podecast 6 The Wonderful Kererū

 


The Wonderful Kererū appears only once in this Podecast but exemplifies the spirit of both participants, a fat, pompous, ridiculous animal snatching a whole twig from the tree of thought, eating a single flower and then throwing the rest away.
 
Contents; 0.07 - VotE. 2.38 - Weightlifters with no penises. 3.37 - Do you want to talk about pre-history? (We do not do this.) 4.36 - I cut a huge amounts of blathering out here. 5.00 - Scraps game. 7.10 - Complexity and depth. 9.30 - Scrap has a moment of clarity about the nature of Complexity. 11.10 - Where it actually starts to get interesting. 11.50 - The capacity of a post-apocalyptic world to create its own context. 13.10 - A new place to put adventures. 13.45 - “What’s his face? The guy who does Udan-Adan? We’ll probably never know his real name.” 14.15 - Our regular obligatory mention of Zak. 15.50 - Who did invent ‘the dungeon as a living thing? 17.28 - A Ghost in my house. 18.30 - The ‘blank slate’ game world & identity. 20.43 - Eve as the first D&D player, Adam as a Storygamer. 22.28 - Rachel Pollack’s ‘Unquenchable Fire’ I got the name wrong in the podcast. 24.26 - Our other regular segment on colonialism. 26.16 - Mention of Potatoes causes internet to drop out. 28.10 - It’s ‘Henry Moreton Stanely’ and I may well be wrong about Cortez. Have fun with Wikipedia. 31.45 - “You’re treating those children like subhumans.” 33.41 - Scrap is confused by the moral exchange inherent to Government. Sarah Horrocks would probably agree. 38.15 - “If only one culture has reliable deep-water navigation, that culture is effectively playing D&D with the world.” 39.45 - Cowboys on Mars. 41.53 - We expand our mentions of Zak to include his sister? Anyway, X-Men school-style Character Gen. 47.39 - Communicating on a Meta-Level. Maybe our players are friends. 49.15 - MY SPECIAL SETTING!! 51.00 - We cycle back to, or around, different contexts in which to place adventures.. 52.00 - The ancient civilization of Dan. 55.09 - The Halfmen of O by Maurice Gee. 56.55 - The Changeover by Margaret Mahy. 58.45 - Does the Conspiracy Theorist have a D&Dish world? No, not really. 60.01 - Pre-apocalyptic D&D. 60.03 - Stealing & faking art throughout history. 60.05 - Dirtbag Greys. The Burke & Hare of space. 60.07 - Changes in scale. Insect wars. 60.08 - The Author was ‘William Tenn’ and the book is Of Men and Monsters. 70.45 - Giants would be very vulnerable, and likely peaceful. 72.55 - The wonderful Kererū or New Zeland Wood Pidgeon. (A bird that flies through the glass in your window is also playing D&D). 76.00 - “Birds would be good D&D characters.” 81.00 - Evil Dolphins.
 
 

2017 - VotE!


The Secret DM — Veins of the Earth Interview with Patrick Stuart and Scrap Princess

 


A text interview about the original ‘Veins of the Earth’.
 
 

2018 - Crystals!


What Would the Smart Party Do? — Episode 80

 
I am not even sure what we talk about here but hopefully Dirks art for Silent Titans gets a mention!
 
Direct MP3: 
http://media.blubrry.com/thesmartparty/content.blubrry.com/thesmartparty/WhatWouldTheSmartPartyDo_80.mp3
 
Page: https://smartparty.wordpress.com/2018/09/13/patrick-stuart-interview/
 
 

The Great Crystal Debate!



The missing interview!!

Back in 2018 I was making my (negative) views on CRYSTALS widely known, when who should step forth to challenge me but the fool and creator of the BREAK! RPG, Reynaldo Mandarinian. To settle the matter for All Time, we got into a SAVAGE hour long verbal dual which, since there seem to be no copies surviving online, I will assume I won.

If anyone out there has any records or copies of the Great Crystal Debate, please let me know in the comments. The world deserves to hear my (assumed) victory, and how crystals were defeated for All Time.
 
 

2019 - The Worm!


Ignite Liverpool — Talk on the Wapentake

I am slightly embarrassed to see myself physically incarnated in maybe my only physical in-person talk.


 
https://youtu.be/nr4KKZMpf6Q
 
Those of you familiar with ‘Silent Titans’ will know about the ‘Wapentake of Wirral’ from that book, based on a real historical incident in which a corrupt lawyer got his hands on the medieval documents giving ownership of a dark age court and used them to form a criminal gang and extort the people of the Wirral.
 

 

The Worm Orouboros with Tom Fitzgerald


In this interview the beloved creator of ‘Middenmurk’, sits down to talk with me about the excellent and under-discovered ‘Worm Ouroboros’ by E.R. Eddison. (One day I will read the Zimiamvia trilogy).






2020 - DCO ReMastered


Loco Ludus — "Interview with Patrick Stuart" 

I have no idea what we talked about, but its 55 minutes long!
 
https://creators.spotify.com/pod/profile/loco-ludus/episodes/Interview-with-Patrick-Stuart-ebgc3h
 
 

‘Udda Ting’ podcast



Henrik Möllers podcast is still going strong. In this one I think we talked mainly about Veins of the Earth.


The Magniloquent Moth

 

Part One show notes (full version at the link); Deep Carbon Observatory (Remastered!), Patrick's talk on the Wapentake at Ignite Liverpool, Silent Titans, The world is a spell, Fear of a Black Dragon (DCO episode), Arnold's "Goblin Punch" blog and time traveling dinosaurs, Veins of the Earth, Fire on the Velvet Horizon, A Night at the Golden Duck, The audio starts to overlap in the second half of the episode, Time travel in RPGs, Continuum RPG.

https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/a-conversation-with-patrick-stuart-first-course/id1506689162?i=1000470707137
 
Part Two show notes CGP Grey's video about why your timeline is infuriating, Is the loose collective of RPG fans online a "community"?, A Distant Mirror, The Gods Must Be Crazy, Patrick's letter writing game (a literal play by post), FLAILSNAILS, Chris McDowall's conversion advice, TROIKA!, Half-Life Alyx, Tom Francis' games, Heat Signature, Tactical Breach Wizards, Deadliest Warrior Yes, there really was an IRA vs the Taliban episode.
 
https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/a-conversation-with-patrick-stuart-second-course/id1506689162?i=1000470707139
 

 

2021 - Groan!


Appendix N Book Club


I actually remember this one and it was fun! I finally got to talk about something other than my own books! This is all about Gormenghast.

Zock Bock Radio

-

Apparently I am, (or was?) the Townes van Zandt of the OSR. I don’t know what that means but I will assume its good! Show notes in the link!

Monsters and Manuals (Noisms), Video Interview

 
 
I am horrified by the sight of my own face so will rush past this one.
 
Blog post: https://monstersandmanuals.blogspot.com/2021/08/video-interview-with-patrick-stuart-of.html
 
Youtube; https://youtu.be/sPhfvkRDxvo
 
 

 2021 -Demon-Bone!


Weird & Wonderful Worlds

Ahh blessed text.
 
http://weirdwonderfulworlds.blogspot.com/2021/08/patrick-stuart-false-machine-interview.html
 
 

Her Christmas Knight




https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8yClMXIjlrM&t=244s
 
 

Whose Measure God Could Not Take



This one covers the Demon-Bone Sarcophagus Kickstarter, Gawain and the OSR community.


2022 - The End!


 "Art" with Her Christmas Knight




https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LOpKlStShCs
 
 

Then, Silence


Or at least, no interviews or appearances from 2022 to 2025 where I popped up in the ‘Weird Hope Engines’ zine fair.
 
Looking back on it, some of these bursts of extroversion were to help with Kickstarters, but it looks like the relative failure of ‘Demon-Bone Sarcophagus’ and the hangover from Covid really fucked me up more than I realised. I may have brought books out but I really didn’t leave the house for years. Damn.
 
Now, once again, I fitfully stumble into action, to prove to myself and the world that I exist.
(Seriously if anyone has a copy of the Great Crystal Debate let me know.)